DISCOURSE *SPARK-ONLINE VERSION 20.0
bittersweet independence

by juli strader

printer friendly version

 

I am trapped. I am a single woman who adheres to the independent woman of the 21st century philosophy. I have not been married before nor do I have children. I am struggling with a career in magazine journalism, desperately trying to support myself financially, with the exception of economical gifts donated by mom and dad, which are gratefully accepted. My life doesn't sound so bad now that it is actually in print, but there is one thing missing, and a rather significant thing at that: a man.

As a young girl I was told that I could be anything I wanted to be. Fair enough. I was also told that I didn't need a man, that I could be independent and be myself, a strong self. True. Drilled into my head was the premise that I should date as many men as I could to learn what qualities I like and dislike in men. I would be jailed for even thinking of getting married young.

I have blindly yet willingly walked into this trap. I didn't foresee independence as a trap. A trap set by the feminists of the sixties and seventies, of the generation that toted placards decreeing "a woman needs a man like a fish needs a bicycle".

Thirty to forty years after Gloria Steinem spoke those words, women like myself are feeling the pressure to be independent. Our parents, society and our beloved girlfriends push us into careers and self-sufficiency. We stand united in sovereign sisterhood and simultaneously we long for a strong shoulder to lean on.

My generation of women has become what our mothers were not. We are living the dream they sought after, fought for and eventually won. Winning isn't everything though. As a product of this propaganda I take pride in my laissez faire independence, but this pride has led me to believe that I can live life quite happily without a male companion. I feel betrayed by my former feminists because that is simply not true.

The popular Bridget Jones' Diary phenomenon presents the situation with liberal accuracy. We go to the office, we go home to our own apartments, and we struggle over what underwear to wear on a date as we hope to meet that one man, our knight in shining armor driving a luxury sport utility vehicle, our prince charming wearing an Armani suit with Kenneth Cole shoes. It's just the usual day-to-day trials and tribulations of a single woman approaching thirty.

What is a woman to do? It is a well-known fact that as one ages, the diminishing dating pool becomes as dry as the desert. The lack of eligible, heterosexual men leads women to focus on their blossoming careers. Comparably, time dedicated to the office can be more interesting than an average date with a guy who thinks you have nice teeth. But then women emerge from the work world in their late twenties or early thirties and realize that these pursuits at a career aren't fulfilling—a dissatisfaction that runs deep.

We chased the dream but now realize we were chasing the wrong one. Women don't like to admit they want a man, let alone need one; it would go against the teachings of the feminist bible. Thanks to our feminist foremothers, women can embrace their sexuality, have meaningless sex in a one-night stand and climb the corporate ladder safe from sexual harassment. But just because we have the freedom to bring a man back to our apartment on a Saturday night doesn't mean we are satisfied with the state of affairs. We want more.

Holding onto our independence with such ferocity, we fear that once we let go it will be gone forever—women are torn between wanting marriage and a family and the freedom to be who they are.

Which begs the question: does a woman relinquish her independence for the sake of marriage? Is getting married the ticket to refunding your independence? Do brides simply exchange independence for a ring, a white dress, and kitchen appliances?

I keep looking for the exit sign, for a secure way out, an escape route to freedom from this trap so dutifully laid out by my mother and her mother, and so many women before me. From one direction women are being pushed to have a corporate career, a personal luxury car and private holidays, but from the opposing direction is the inner pull to find companionship, find the love poets write about, and raise a family. Our mothers suggest we can have both because they want us to have what they didn't: identity outside the family.

Copyright © 2001 Juli Strader. All Rights Reserved.

Juli Strader in a writer living in Toronto who, apparently, has nice teeth.

 

 

comment? discuss this article on our discussion board

subscribe: enter your email address to receive information and updates